Consultation Case | Verbal Abuse Against a Subcontracted Employee, Resolved Through Workplace Harassment Legal Consultation

1. Workplace Harassment: Where Does the Law Draw the Line?

Workplace harassment refers to conduct that exploits a position of authority or relational advantage to inflict physical or psychological distress, or to deteriorate working conditions, beyond what is acceptable in the course of work. Verbal abuse, humiliation, exclusion, and unreasonable work instructions are among the most common examples.

The Labor Standards Act strictly regulates this conduct, requiring employers to carry out prompt and fair investigations, protect victims, and take disciplinary action against perpetrators. In practice, however, victims often bear the burden of proving what happened themselves.

Courts have interpreted workplace harassment broadly, actively recognizing conduct that causes psychological distress or deteriorates working conditions. This is treated not as a simple workplace conflict but as a serious legal matter involving a violation of the worker's personal rights. If you are experiencing workplace harassment, consulting a legal specialist to protect your rights is strongly recommended.

2. A Consultation Case: Verbal Abuse by a Prime Contractor's Supervisor Against a Subcontracted Employee

A had been working alongside employees of a prime contractor for over three years as an employee of a subcontractor. Following a work error, A's supervisor from the prime contractor publicly berated A in front of other employees for an extended period. The humiliation and shock caused A to faint and sustain a facial injury from the fall — yet the company took no appropriate medical steps that day. A ultimately resigned and began receiving psychiatric treatment. The supervisor made contact on several occasions afterward, but the calls were perfunctory, with no sincere apology.

A considered taking legal action and requested a consultation with Sugar Square Law & Advisors.

3. Sugar Square's Advice: The Company Bears Responsibility for Workplace Harassment

This case is a textbook example of workplace harassment. In consultation with A, Sugar Square provided the following guidance.

• Where verbal abuse is carried out publicly in the workplace for ten minutes or more, this constitutes clear workplace harassment. Even where the perpetrator is a supervisor from a prime contractor acting against a subcontracted employee, the prime contractor may also bear liability where its authority to direct and manage was being exercised at the time.

• Where the verbal abuse rises to the level of insult or defamation, the public nature of the conduct may support a criminal complaint.

• Even without a criminal complaint, it is possible to file a report with the Labor Relations Commission for workplace harassment. If the company fails to separate the victim from the perpetrator or take disciplinary action, a further complaint targeting the representative director is also available.

• Where an employee resigns as a result of workplace harassment — as A did — unemployment benefits remain available if the harassment is recognized.

Separately, while proving workplace harassment through evidence presents its own challenges if the matter proceeds to litigation, a civil claim for consolation damages is available. The level of compensation varies depending on the severity of the conduct and the physical and psychological harm suffered by the victim.

4. Workplace Harassment: Consult Before You Endure Any Further

Following the consultation with Sugar Square, A reached a settlement with the company at a meeting — two months' salary, severance pay, and unemployment benefits as the agreed terms. The company, feeling the pressure of A's preparations for legal proceedings, chose early resolution. As A had no wish to pursue litigation, the matter concluded there.

Are you in a situation like A's? Sugar Square provides specialist legal advice and practical experience in protecting workers' rights in workplace harassment cases. Even without retaining an attorney for litigation, an early consultation can open up a clear path forward. Don't carry this alone — reach out to Sugar Square.

[CONTACT]

• Tel: 02-563-5877

• Kakao Talk: Search '법무법인슈가스퀘어' or Kakao Talk link

• e-mail: sugar@sugar.legal

• 7, Teheran-ro 113-gil, Gangnam-gu, Seoul, Republic of Korea
  Baekam-Art center 2F